Butter chicken: a dish with a disputed origin story
TL;DR: Butter chicken is chicken in a tomato-and-butter gravy. It is closely associated with Moti Mahal, with a rich sauce for scooping up with naan or spooning over rice.
Contents

Butter chicken has one of the most appealing leftovers stories in the curry repertoire. In the familiar account, restaurant cooks put drying tandoori chicken into a tomato-and-butter gravy to keep it moist. The combination is easy to picture: roasted meat wrapped in a silky sauce, with butter and cream softening the tomato’s acidity. Tear off a piece of naan and there is plenty of gravy to gather around the chicken.
Partition, Delhi, and a Tandoor
The story centers on Moti Mahal and cooks whose lives connected Peshawar and Delhi around Partition. Kundan Lal Gujral and Kundan Lal Jaggi both appear in accounts of butter chicken's development. A frequently repeated explanation has tandoori chicken meeting a tomato-and-butter gravy to keep it moist. That describes the dish's logic beautifully: roasted meat and a sauce that coats it rather than a dry piece of chicken on its own. The gravy also gives the dish a different serving rhythm: each piece of chicken comes with enough sauce to spoon over rice or scoop with bread.
The Courtroom Twist
In 2024, the Moti Mahal and Daryaganj restaurant families took their competing invention claims to the Delhi High Court. One account emphasizes Gujral; the other emphasizes Jaggi. Family photographs, recollections and restaurant histories formed part of the argument. The dispute shows how closely a signature dish can become tied to a restaurant’s identity. For the diner, the recognizable features remain tomato gravy, butter, cream and chicken, even as families tell different stories about the first pot.
Why the World Fell for It
Its appeal starts in the sauce: tomato gives the gravy its foundation, butter and cream enrich it, and spices keep it from being merely a creamy sauce. Recipes vary in heat and richness. Chicken tikka masala is another restaurant favorite built around chicken and sauce, with its own seasonings and preparation. Naan offers one way to gather the gravy; rice is another companion. Tear, scoop, repeat, or spoon the gravy through a mound of warm rice.
- Tandoori chicken: char and smoke, the flavor foundation
- Tomato-butter gravy: sweet, tangy, and dangerously spoonable
- Cream and kasuri methi: the finishing luxury and the haunting aroma
Preparation varies as well as the story. Butter-chicken recipes may marinate the chicken before roasting or other cooking, then finish it in gravy. The linked home version starts with raw chicken in a pan and uses tomato, butter and cream. It is a stovetop adaptation, not a reconstruction of a particular restaurant's tandoor method.
Cook at home: Butter chicken, Garlic naan.
Sources
✍️ Written by the PhantomBite editorial team for the joy of it. Food history is often contested — where the record is murky, we say so rather than pretend to certainty. Recipes are written from general cooking knowledge; preparation times are estimates. The delivery is fictional.
